Home
Information Radio 
Network
News Commentaries
News Links
Affilliates




Obama Eligibility dispute, Part 2, scheduled by Supremes
By: irnnews IRN | Source: WorldNetDaily.com
December 9, 2008 7:55AM EST


Court rejects claim challenging candidacy, schedules another for Friday conference


Posted: December 08, 2008
8:54 pm Eastern

By Bob Unruh
© 2008 WorldNetDaily

Not even the U.S. Supreme Court can kill the dispute that has developed over Sen. Barack Obama's eligibility to occupy the Oval Office based on questions raised over his birthplace and citizenship and his steadfast refusal to provide documentation on the issue.

The high court Monday denied a request to listen to arguments in a case, Donofrio v. Wells, from New Jersey that addressed the issues. But literally within minutes, the court's website confirmed that another conference is scheduled for Friday on another case raising the same worries.

The case of Leo C. Donofrio v. New Jersey Secretary of State Nina Mitchell Wells claimed Obama does not meet the Constitution's Article 2, Section 1 "natural-born citizen" requirement for president because of his dual citizenship at birth.

The new case, Cort Wrotnowski v. Susan Bysiewicz, Connecticut secretary of state, also makes a dual citizenship argument. It had been rejected by Justice Ruth Ginsburg Nov. 26 but then was resubmitted to Justice Antonin Scalia. There was no word of its fate for about 10 days, then today the court's website confirmed it has been distributed for Friday's conference, a meeting at which the justices consider whether to take cases.

Where's the proof Barack Obama was born in the U.S. or that he fulfills the "natural-born American" clause in the Constitution? If you still want to see it, sign WND's petition demanding the release of his birth certificate.

Donofrio, whose case was rejected today, said he's hopeful Wrotnowski's complaint will find a more receptive panel.

"It includes a more solid brief and a less treacherous lower court procedural history," Donofrio writes on his Natural Born Citizen blog. "I must stress that [Wrotnowski] does not have the same procedural hang up that mine does."

The website explained an appeals judge in New Jersey had incorrectly characterized Donofrio's original complaint as a "motion for leave to appeal" rather than a "direct appeal."

"If Cort's application is also denied then the fat lady can sing," the website stated. "Until then, the same exact issue is before SCOTUS as was in my case. Cort's application before SCOTUS incorporates all of the arguments and law in mine, but we improved on the arguments in Cort's quite a bit as we had more time to prepare it."

Besides the plaintiffs for these two and about a dozen other legal actions that challenge Obama's eligibility in courts around the country, there are tens of thousands of people who are alarmed by the unanswered questions about Obama.

More than 60,000 letters were generated by WND readers specifically asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review Obama's eligibility.


The campaign included 6,682 packages of nine letters each delivered to the court on the case about Obama's eligibility under the "a natural born citizen" requirement.

"If we didn't do everything possible to let the Supreme Court justices know what a concern this is to millions of Americans, I would feel like I was letting down the Constitution and the men who framed it – not to mention every citizen of the United States living now and in the future," Joseph Farah, WND's founder and editor, said of the campaign. "This constitutional eligibility test has become a key issue with me because if the plain language of the Constitution is no longer taken seriously by our nation's controlling legal authorities, we have become an outlaw nation – no longer under the rule of law but under the rule of men."

A petition drive Farah launched also has collected more than 175,000 signatures – so far – from people who want to know the truth.

Last month WND reported worries over a "constitutional crisis" that could be looming over the issue of Obama's citizenship. The concerns were raised in a lawsuit in California asking state officials to prevent Electoral College members from voting for Obama until they investigated his eligibility, a case being handled by the United States Justice Foundation.

WND senior reporter Jerome Corsi had gone both to Kenya and Hawaii prior to the election to investigate issues surrounding Obama's birth. But his research and discoveries only raised more questions.

The biggest question is why Obama, if a Hawaii birth certificate exists as his campaign has stated, hasn't simply ordered it made available to settle the rumors.

The governor's office in Hawaii said there is a valid certificate but rejected requests for access and left ambiguous its origin: Does the certificate on file with the Department of Health indicate a Hawaii birth or was it generated after the Obama family registered a Kenyan birth in Hawaii?

Obama's half-sister, Maya Soetoro, has named two different Hawaii hospitals where Obama could have been born. There have been other allegations that Obama actually was born in Kenya during a time when his father was a British subject. A one point a Kenyan ambassador said Obama's birthplace in Kenya already was being recognized.

Among the plaintiffs in the California case is presidential candidate Alan Keyes.

"Should Senator Obama be discovered, after he takes office, to be ineligible for the office of president of the United States of America and, thereby, his election declared void, petitioners, as well as other Americans, will suffer irreparable harm in that (a) usurper will be sitting as the president of the United States, and none of the treaties, laws, or executive orders signed by him will be valid or legal," the action challenges.

Wrotnowski's case challenges the courts to review allegations of election fraud, suggesting the Connecticut secretary of state should not have placed Obama's name on the ballot without verification of his eligibility.

After state courts refused to take the case, he said the point was, "this document has not been produced."

"I'm not the first, not the last, just among a growing number of people across the country who've become distressed about the lack of disclosure,"

Donofrio had alleged that Obama's dual citizenship disqualifies him. Obama's campaign said the British citizenship expired, leaving him with "natural-born" U.S. citizenship.

Obama's Fight the Smears website confirms Donofrio is correct about the Democrat's citizenship at birth.

Donofrio's case originally was denied a conference of the judges by Justice David H. Souter, but Justice Clarence Thomas agreed to bring it back for consideration last week. To go forward, from conference to a full hearing, the case needed the approval of four of the Supreme Court's nine justices.

Also, the "certification of live birth" posted by the Obama campaign cannot be viewed as authoritative, critics allege.

"Hawaii Revised Statute 338-178 allows registration of birth in Hawaii for a child that was born outside of Hawaii to parents who, for a year preceding the child’s birth, claimed Hawaii as their place of residence," according to reports. "The only way to know where Senator Obama was actually born is to view Senator Obama's original birth certificate from 1961 that shows the name of the hospital and the name and signature of the doctor that delivered him."

Critics also raise the circumstances of Obama's time during his youth in Indonesia, where he was listed as having Indonesian citizenship. Indonesia does not allow dual citizenship, raising the possibility of Obama's mother having given up his U.S. citizenship.

Any subsequent U.S. citizenship then, the case claims, would be "naturalized," not "natural-born."

WND's petition is available online, and more information is available at this link.

Email this Article Printer Friendly Version

Related Articles
- WorldNetDaily Expose: Meet Obama's new Bill Ayers associate
- Obama Falsely Claims 'Every Penny' of Bailout Proceeds Will Go to Americans
- Few Details Known About Obama’s Three Weeks in Pakistan
- Obama Going to ‘Bankrupt’ Coal Industry, Critics Warn
- Obama Ally Dedicated 1974 Book to RFK Assassin
- IBD/TIPP Poll: McCain and Obama in Statistical Tie
- Poll: Obama Fails to Gain Among Churchgoers
- Doubts persist about Obama birth certificate
- OBAMA TRIED TO STALL GIS' IRAQ WITHDRAWAL
- Obama’s Chicago Needs Change First
- FBI Informant Implicates Obama Associate in Murder
- Crossing Paths Daily: Obama and Ayers Shared an Office (Update: For Three Years)
- Boston Housing Agency Barred from Checking Obama’s Aunt’s Immigrant Status
- Obama’s Trade, Security Stances Concern Some in Asia
- Coal Officials Blast Obama Over Remarks
- What you don't know about Barack Obama
- Obama speechwriter defects to McCain
- America proclaims: Obama is 'the One'
- Obama May Spend on Highways, Bridges to Stimulate U.S. Economy
- Obama Leveraged Record Fundraising, Spending to Defeat Rivals
- Obama Victory Means ‘Stronger Gun Laws’
- Obama May Not Wait for Inauguration to Put His Stamp on Economy
- Faith-Based Hospitals Could Close If Obama Signs Freedom of Choice Act
- HOMELESS 'DRIVEN' TO VOTE OBAMA
- Chavez, Allies Applaud Obama Victory
- Obama aims at broad shift in national security
- Obama Nominees Signal Radical Pro-U.N. Agenda
- Obama Fundraising Sealed Election Win
- Obama Health-Care Plan Collides With Financial-Crisis Spending
- Obama campaign workers angry over unpaid wages
- Obama Could End Abstinence Education in Fight Against AIDS
- Obama and ACORN: You Can Run But You Can’t Hide
- Obama Earmarks Benefited Donors and Relatives, Group Says
- Thai court disbands governing party
- Prosecutors for Obama hunting for 'lying ads'
- Kissiner Repudiates Obama Debate Claim
- The Real Obama Part II
- Team Obama Spin Lies About Ayers
- The Real Obama
- Obama's Real Problem With Ayers
- Obama, DNC elude citizenship lawsuit deadline
- Barack Obama and the Hiss Denier
- Generic Heart Medicines Found Equal to Brand-Name Counterparts
- Obama Campaign Runs Afoul of Finance Rules
- Pro-Amnesty Activist Joins Obama White House Staff
- Obama Selects Pro-abortion Activist as White House Communications Director
- Obama shelves oil company tax after price fall: aide
- Pravda raises Obama eligibility issue
- Obama economic adviser was socialist party member?
- OBAMA’S ROLE IN THE SUBPRIME COLLAPSE: The ACORN Connection
- Obama, Ayers, and the Politics of Intimidation
- Survey: CEOs Say Obama Would Be Disastrous
- Proof Obama backed ruthless, foreign thug
- Farrakhan on Obama: 'The Messiah is absolutely speaking'
- Obama, Ayers, and the Politics of Intimidation
- Barack Obama's Terrorist Connections
- Mideast leader: Obama a Muslim who studied in Islamic schools
- IN THEIR OWN WORDS: McCain, Obama on 'gay rights'
- Will Supreme Court take case on Obama's citizenship?
- Al Gore Out of Mix as Obama Mulls Environment Posts
- 'Smears' About Obama Largely True
- Obama Plans Largest Building Program Since 1950s
- Obama's Economic Plan for America
- Why I Can't Vote For Obama
- Is Obama a “transformational figure”? You don’t know the half of it!
- Obama campaign selling Chicago election night coverage packages to news outlets
- Conservative Leaders Meet, Plan to Battle Obama’s Agenda – With or Without Republicans
- Iran Not Interested in Obama’s ‘Carrots’
- Obama Turns Blind Eye to Credit Card Donation Fraud
- Obama 'admits' Kenyan birth?
- Muslim plea to Obama: Return to 'Islamic roots'
- Obama Pays Women Only 78 Percent of What He Pays Men
- Obama’s Chief of Staff Pick Took Campaign Contributions from Wall Street
- Obama Tries the Parliamentary System
- Murdoch: Obama's economic policies are 'naive'
- Obama ad goes to war with abortion survivor
- Obama weighs quick undoing of Bush policy
- Abortion Groups Confident Obama Will Push His Pro-Abortion Agenda
- Almost 90 Percent of Muslims Voted for Obama Despite Differences on Abortion, Marriage
- Washington Post Admits they Were Favorable to Obama in Reporting
- Georgia Senate Race Key to Stopping Obama Agenda
- Supreme Court denies Obama citizenship challenge
- Even now, plans under way for Obama national holiday
- Economy won't stop Obama's priorities, aides say
- Should Christians Honor Barack Obama?
- Obama Picks Eric Holder to Be Attorney General, Newsweek Says
- Obama pledges state to Palestinian leader
- Obama Campaign Ad Targets Abortion Survivor
- UMass chaplain offered credits to students who would campaign for Obama
- Obama’s ‘Change’ Likely to Include Funding Abortions Abroad
- Congressman Broun says Obama 'Marxist'
- Obama’s ‘New Deal’ Not Likely to Cure Economy or Unemployment Rate, Free Market Economists Say
- Frank: Auto Bailout Will Come Back After Obama Takes Office
- 4 Weathermen terrorists declare support for Obama
- Obama Invents 'Office of the President-Elect'
- Communist Party ecstatic over '08 election results
- Open Border Immigration Groups Mobilize to Push for ‘Pathway to Legalization’ Under Obama
- Catholic Bishops Will Fight Obama on Abortion
- Okay for Obamas to Send Their Kids to Private Schools, Teachers’ Union President Says
- Supremes to review Barack's citizenship
- N.Y. Times Confirms Suspicious Obama Donations
- Is Obama Following the Leninist Line?
- Audit of Obama Fundraising Unlikely
- Obama Pushes for $50 Billion for Automakers, Oversight Czar
- Despite Campaign Claim, Obama Told Paper He Attended Trinity Church ‘Every Week’
- Obama grant being probed
- Germany to Obama: No More Troops for Afghanistan
- Obama Will Change Balance on Courts Quickly
- Gun Owners Not Welcome on Obama's White House Team?
- Swearing in: Barack Hussein Obama
- “OBAMA MANIA”
- Barack Obama gives campaign staffers extra cash, BlackBerrys, laptops
- 'Constitutional crisis' looming over Obama's birth location
- `Sons of Iraq' Fight Terrorism, Beg Obama to Keep Troops There
- Blagojevich Scandal: What Did Obama Know, and When Did He Know It?
- Rezko Tie Links Obama and Blagojevich
- Palin Attacks Obama’s ‘Appalling’ Refusal to Defend Babies Who Survive Abortion
- Obama didn't write 'Dreams from My Father'
- Obama website lies about ACORN ties
- RNC Chairman Calls on Obama to Disclose Communications with Blagojevich
- Obama-Run Foundation Gave Millions to Liberal Groups, Including One Run by Bill Ayers
- Clever Obama Tries To Bury ACORN Past
- Will Obama Fire Patrick Fitzgerald?
- Obama Getting Support From Gaza Strip
- Obama’s Credit Card Scheme Gets Noticed
- Obama's law firm led charge benefiting socialist party
- Obama and the Law
- Ex-FBI Agents Outraged at Obama-Ayers Ties
- Obama, ACORN, and Contempt for Election Law
- Obama-Led Foundation Spent $49 Million But Had 'Little Impact' on Improving Chicago Schools
- Obama’s Tax Cut is Actually a Spending Increase, Says Non-Partisan Group
- Report: Sarkozy Views Obama's Stance on Iran As 'Utterly Immature'
- McCain campaign accuses L.A. Times of 'suppressing' Obama video
- Wayne Huizenga may rush sale of Dolphins for fear of Barack Obama raising taxes
- Obama's unsavory ties
- Obama donor ordered Big Brother probe of Joe the Plumber
- Experts affirm: Ayers' wrote Obama's memoir
- Stop Misquoting Us, Conservative Group Tells Obama Campaign
- Marxist 'mentor' sold drugs with Obama
- Ex-CIA Expert: Obama Took Millions in Illegal Foreign Donations
- Obama and McCain offer clear choice between economic plans
- Obama raised $1 million for foreign thug's election
- Obama's Long Record of Flip-Flops Exposed
- Obama Contributors Emerged from Staff and Boards of Annenberg Grantees
- Breyer, Souter are Obama’s Models for Supreme Court Choices, Advisor Says
- Supremes asked to halt Tuesday's vote
- Confirmed: Obama friend closely tied to terror group
- The Christian Case Against Barack Obama
- Obama’s Secret Campaign Cash: Has $63 Million Flowed from Foreign Sources?
- Powell Is Wrong about Obama's Muslim Past
- Obama funded foreign thug who promised Islamic state
- Al-Jazeera for Obama
- Obama is no Robin Hood
- Obama Wants Israel Back to 1967 Borders
- Communist Party strategist maps out Obama's agenda
- Obama Declares War on Conservative Talk Radio
- McCain almost tied with Obama in One Day Polling
- Barack Obama’s family in Kenya stops media interviews
- Obama's aunt living in U.S. illegally
- Obama Wrote Federal Staffers About His Goals
- Soros-Funded Democratic Idea Factory Becomes Obama Policy Source
- Elections Officials May Audit Obama's Fundraising Machine
- Obama's AG Choice was Key Figure in Clinton Terrorist Clemency Controversy
- Obama Pick of Craig Worries Cuban-Americans
- Obama Selecting the Most Anti-Life, Anti-Family Radicals He Can Find for Administration
- Obama Wants 12 Million Illegals to Get Citizenship
- Focus on the Family peers into future of Obama win
- Clinton ‘On Track’ for State; Obama Near on Security Adviser
- Is Obama Embarking On Bill Clinton's Third Term?
- Obama-Led Foundation Funded A Group Led by Former Chair of "Communist Party (Marxist-Leninist)"
- Surprise! New York Times endorses Obama for president
- NRA’s Magazine Assails Obama on Gun Control
- Newspaper shows Obama belonged to socialist party
- Extreme Pro-Abortion Leader Chosen for Obama Communications Director
- VP debate moderator Ifill releasing pro-Obama book
- The Washington insider who made Obama rich
- Obama Emulates FDR’s Kennedy Pick With Rubin Clan in ‘Henhouse’
- Biden Wrong About ACORN-Obama Connection
- Hillary Backers Decry Massive Obama Vote Fraud
- Obama's birth certificate sealed by Hawaii governor
- Obama and "The Left"
- The Obama Temptation
- Obama’s Small Donor Juggernaut More Myth than Reality, Report Shows
- Kenya: 'I don't know' if Obama born in U.S.
- Liberals Angry over Obama's Pick of Gates, Jones

Home| Search| News Archives| Email Administrator| Login| Get Syndicated Content